A safety paper identifies a new agent failure. How do you turn the finding into requirements and a release decision?
Make your call first. Use the published answer and rubric to examine your reasoning when you are ready.
Case briefRead the inputs, then make your call
A research finding suggests an agent can be induced to send private content to an external destination. Your document assistant can propose sends. All operating figures are fictional.
| Proposed load | 100 sends per day; 10% expected to need specialist review. |
|---|---|
| Review capacity | 12 minutes per review; 90 reviewer-minutes available daily. |
| Representative trial | Zero leaks in 400 independently sampled attempts under a fixed policy. Examine whether those assumptions hold. |
| Other evidence | An adversarial test suite covers selected attack classes; it is not a random sample of production attempts. |
| Open questions | The product-specific failure has not yet been reproduced, and enforcement of destination permissions needs verification. |
Your task. Translate the finding into requirements, calculate review capacity and interpret the trial. Recommend a bounded release or restriction with explicit reversal criteria.
0 words